Math GPT, just like ChatGPT but with video generation capabilities

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering a space where AI is increasingly being used to generate videos, particularly in the educational and explainer space. The good news is that there's high engagement in this category, which means there is definitely an audience. With 11 similar products, you're facing a competitive market, so differentiation is key. Many users in similar launches were excited about the potential to simplify video creation, but they also noted issues like nonsensical outputs, poor video quality, and technical glitches, indicating that execution matters greatly. Since this falls into the freemium model, you have to offer enough value for free to attract users while also offering premium features that people will pay for. Given the criticisms for similar "MathGPT" products (unfunny humor, potentially harmful/incorrect information), it's imperative you focus on accuracy, clarity and reliability.

Recommendations

  1. Given that you are in a freemium space, start by clearly identifying the core value proposition of your free version. Which users will get the most value from the free product? Understanding this will guide your development and marketing efforts. Since the launch of "MathGPT" had issues around accuracy, prioritize building a highly accurate and reliable core before expanding features.
  2. Since you're offering a Math GPT, consider what specific math problems are the most appropriate and useful to address with video generation (calculus, linear algebra, etc). Focus on those niches and create premium features specifically tailored to solving these problems. For instance, offer step-by-step visual solutions or customizable video outputs.
  3. Instead of a consumer model, explore a B2B angle by catering to teams of educators or tutors rather than individual students. Create team-based collaboration features, analytics, or branding options which will increase the incentive to pay for your product. This could be crucial for scaling in this competitive market, since comments indicate people want to use it but might not want to pay.
  4. Offer personalized help, consulting, or onboarding to paying customers. Many users get lost or overwhelmed in AI-based systems, so providing a human touch can improve retention and justify a premium price point. Given negative feedback about lack of visual step-by-step solutions in other Math GPT tools, make sure you provide that as a feature.
  5. Experiment with different pricing models and tiers. Run A/B tests on small groups of users to see which pricing strategies resonate most effectively. Consider offering usage-based pricing or feature-based tiers, or even a combination of these. Since there are a lot of products with video generation in ChatGPT, look for a different hook.
  6. Address the video quality issues raised in similar products. Invest in high-quality stock footage, animations, and ensure smooth rendering. Poor visuals can quickly turn users away. Perhaps test your video generation on different browsers, as some competitors have experienced issues with specific browsers.
  7. Tackle potential copyright concerns by clearly stating the sources of your stock footage and ensuring that all generated content is copyright-safe. Users in similar AI tools have voiced concerns regarding copyright infringements and legal risks.

Questions

  1. Given the criticism that many AI video tools generate 'nonsensical' videos, how will you ensure that your Math GPT creates videos that are coherent, mathematically accurate, and pedagogically sound?
  2. Considering the potential for Math GPT to provide harmful or incorrect information, what specific validation and quality control measures will you implement to ensure accuracy and prevent the dissemination of misleading content?
  3. Based on the fact that other freemium AI video tools struggled with user accessibility (waitlists, upgrade requirements), how do you plan to balance offering a free version while still creating a compelling incentive for users to upgrade to a paid plan?

Your are here

You're entering a space where AI is increasingly being used to generate videos, particularly in the educational and explainer space. The good news is that there's high engagement in this category, which means there is definitely an audience. With 11 similar products, you're facing a competitive market, so differentiation is key. Many users in similar launches were excited about the potential to simplify video creation, but they also noted issues like nonsensical outputs, poor video quality, and technical glitches, indicating that execution matters greatly. Since this falls into the freemium model, you have to offer enough value for free to attract users while also offering premium features that people will pay for. Given the criticisms for similar "MathGPT" products (unfunny humor, potentially harmful/incorrect information), it's imperative you focus on accuracy, clarity and reliability.

Recommendations

  1. Given that you are in a freemium space, start by clearly identifying the core value proposition of your free version. Which users will get the most value from the free product? Understanding this will guide your development and marketing efforts. Since the launch of "MathGPT" had issues around accuracy, prioritize building a highly accurate and reliable core before expanding features.
  2. Since you're offering a Math GPT, consider what specific math problems are the most appropriate and useful to address with video generation (calculus, linear algebra, etc). Focus on those niches and create premium features specifically tailored to solving these problems. For instance, offer step-by-step visual solutions or customizable video outputs.
  3. Instead of a consumer model, explore a B2B angle by catering to teams of educators or tutors rather than individual students. Create team-based collaboration features, analytics, or branding options which will increase the incentive to pay for your product. This could be crucial for scaling in this competitive market, since comments indicate people want to use it but might not want to pay.
  4. Offer personalized help, consulting, or onboarding to paying customers. Many users get lost or overwhelmed in AI-based systems, so providing a human touch can improve retention and justify a premium price point. Given negative feedback about lack of visual step-by-step solutions in other Math GPT tools, make sure you provide that as a feature.
  5. Experiment with different pricing models and tiers. Run A/B tests on small groups of users to see which pricing strategies resonate most effectively. Consider offering usage-based pricing or feature-based tiers, or even a combination of these. Since there are a lot of products with video generation in ChatGPT, look for a different hook.
  6. Address the video quality issues raised in similar products. Invest in high-quality stock footage, animations, and ensure smooth rendering. Poor visuals can quickly turn users away. Perhaps test your video generation on different browsers, as some competitors have experienced issues with specific browsers.
  7. Tackle potential copyright concerns by clearly stating the sources of your stock footage and ensuring that all generated content is copyright-safe. Users in similar AI tools have voiced concerns regarding copyright infringements and legal risks.

Questions

  1. Given the criticism that many AI video tools generate 'nonsensical' videos, how will you ensure that your Math GPT creates videos that are coherent, mathematically accurate, and pedagogically sound?
  2. Considering the potential for Math GPT to provide harmful or incorrect information, what specific validation and quality control measures will you implement to ensure accuracy and prevent the dissemination of misleading content?
  3. Based on the fact that other freemium AI video tools struggled with user accessibility (waitlists, upgrade requirements), how do you plan to balance offering a free version while still creating a compelling incentive for users to upgrade to a paid plan?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 11
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 32
  • Net use signal: 19.7%
    • Positive use signal: 21.2%
    • Negative use signal: 1.5%
  • Net buy signal: -0.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.8%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

MathGPT – Create math animations for any question

Hi, we're MathGPT! MathGPT creates Khan-Academy-style animated math videos that intuitively explain complex concepts to students, helping them understand how to solve their problems step-by-step. We're currently serving over 2M users, processing 800M tokens / day and growing! If you try it out, we would appreciate feedback on how we can make the overall experience / video generation better! Email me at ygk2[at]cornell.edu.

Users criticized the Show HN product for its attempts at humor being unfunny and the potential for providing harmful information. Technical issues were highlighted, including plot errors, discrepancies between video and text, incorrect calculations, and mispronunciations leading to confusion. The product's educational content was deemed lacking in focus and clarity, with unreliable math solutions and video generation problems. Users also noted errors in plotting and a lack of transparency regarding profit status and the model used. The video's failure to show work was also criticized as reducing its usefulness.


Avatar
84
24
-8.3%
-8.3%
24
84
8.3%
Relevance

VideoGPT by VEED - Generate amazing videos directly in ChatGPT

Create insanely good videos directly in ChatGPT using only text. All you need to do is describe what video you want to make and sit back while VideoGPT generates a fully edited video in seconds, including stock footage, music, text-to-voice, and more!

The launch of VideoGPT on Product Hunt garnered considerable excitement and positive feedback, with users praising its potential to simplify and accelerate video creation. Many highlighted its ease of use, impressive editing capabilities, and the innovative text-to-video concept. Several users reported success in generating videos, while some experienced issues such as incoherent video creation or overload errors. A few users inquired about video quality, stock footage sources, image copyright, and compatibility with specific GPT models. Suggestions for improvement included integrating Eleven Labs voice and enabling user video uploads for automated editing.

Users criticized the tool for generating nonsensical videos with random stock footage and music, raising copyright concerns. The video quality was deemed terrible, and creation failures due to overload were reported. Some users felt it was late to the AI video kit market. Concerns were raised regarding the need for a CPT+ upgrade with a waitlist and questions about user accessibility and future challenges. There were also specific issues mentioned such as users needing to update the text or voice.


Avatar
530
60
35.0%
1.7%
60
530
35.0%
1.7%
Relevance

VEED GPT 2.0 - The best way to create pro-level videos using only text

VideoGPT 2.0 is here! VideoGPT helps you create amazing videos using only text. Now, you can add subtitles, use an avatar, generate b-roll, plug in music, and so much more. Then, sit back whilst VideoGPT generates a fully edited, pro-level video in seconds.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and praising the product as a game-changer for content creators. Many highlighted the impressive features of VideoGPT 2.0, particularly its video production capabilities and the potential of prompt-to-video technology. Users found it easy to use for creating explainer videos and were excited about the future of video generation. Some users expressed high hopes for the project's success and appreciated the product's usefulness, likability, and potential for accelerating video processes. A few users also offered suggestions, such as uploading personal images instead of AI-generated ones.

Several users expressed concerns regarding the product's effectiveness and its ability to deliver the promised results, with some doubting its efficiency based on past experiences with similar slow or poor-performing products. A suggestion was made to explore alternative video segments that would better showcase the product's value.


Avatar
235
36
25.0%
36
235
25.0%
Relevance

Pictory GPT for Videos - Quickly create stunning videos right in ChatGPT

Generate engaging video from your ideas or assets in minutes. Powered by ChatGPT and optimized for video by Pictory. Easily target your content by audience, language, platform, use case, and more. Copyright free.

The Product Hunt launch of Pictory GPT received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users expressing excitement about its innovative AI integration, ease of use, and time-saving capabilities for video creation. Many users congratulated the team and highlighted the seamless integration with ChatGPT. Some users faced issues like Firefox preview problems, LinkedIn access issues, video generation stalls, and limitations with video length and voiceover time. There were also queries regarding API access, watermarks, trial without subscription and integration with GPT-4.

Several users reported technical issues including Firefox preview problems, LinkedIn access failures, and stalled video generation. Pictory AI's script-to-video tool and GPT integration also faced criticisms related to functionality, accuracy, and cost. Some users found the tool buggy, time-consuming, and no easier than manual methods, citing irrelevant video outputs, ignored prompts, and latency issues. Limitations such as video length and errors preventing video creation led to frustration, alongside concerns about the tool's value compared to alternatives and the clarity of its branding features.


Avatar
620
136
25.7%
0.7%
136
620
27.2%
2.2%
Relevance

AI Powered Video Generator - Easily bring your ideas to life with AI generated videos

ChatGPT meets video with our new Idea to Video feature (available on both mobile and desktop!). Just type in a few words and instantly get a video with a compelling story and visuals that you can share with your team, your customers, and your community!

Visla's AI video generator is receiving overwhelmingly positive feedback for its ease of use, time-saving capabilities, and ability to quickly create professional-quality videos from simple ideas. Users are excited about its potential for marketing, social media, and various business/personal applications. The AI-powered features, smooth onboarding, and supportive team are frequently praised. Many congratulate the team on the successful launch, expressing eagerness to try the tool and anticipating future enhancements, including image generation.

Users have expressed concerns about the limited customization options for branding in AI videos. Some users reported difficulty in creating videos due to a lack of program knowledge. There are also concerns about the AI's ability to accurately represent the user's initial idea. The range of images needs improvement for the SaaS, as some users have observed that they are typical stock photos.


Avatar
300
58
48.3%
58
300
48.3%
Relevance

Math Solver GPT - Get instant math solutions by uploading an image

Math Solver GPT is your AI-powered math whiz, tackling anything from algebra to calculus. Just snap a pic of your problem and get instant solutions!

The launch received positive feedback and congratulations, with users highlighting its potential as a great learning tool and math solver. Questions arose regarding its correctness, ability to handle complex reasoning tasks, and the timing of the launch relative to school days. Overall, users are enthusiastic about its educational applications.

The primary criticisms of the Product Hunt launch include disappointment regarding the product's delayed release. Also, a user inquired whether the tool provides step-by-step instructions or explanations within the product.


Avatar
115
7
14.3%
7
115
14.3%
Relevance

GPT Slides Maker - ChatGPT convert text prompts, video, PDF, web page to Slides

Support from text, pdf, video, url to generate slide™, Support for 30+ mainstream languages, AI-generated Images for Slides™.

The product launch is receiving positive feedback, with users praising its design and idea. There's interest in Canva integration. One user offered to list the app in AI directories. Congratulations are extended to the team on the launch.


Avatar
94
5
5
94
Relevance

Trellis - ChatGPT and GPT-3-powered textbook companion and tutor

Trellis is your custom teacher. Explain code and formulae in plain English, simplify complicated prose, translate into a different language, and generate a diagram or visualization from any phrase.

Trellis's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its interactive, customizable AI education and pleasurable UI/UX. Many are excited about its potential to simplify complex topics, personalize learning, and transform education. Users appreciate its accessibility and usefulness, particularly for those intimidated by AI. Questions arose regarding the product's name, roadmap, how it helps teachers scale quality education, and its best subject areas. Several users congratulated the team and expressed excitement about using Trellis.

Users criticized the product launch for not mentioning AI in the title, leading to a potentially misleading impression. There was feedback regarding the generic, 'one-size-fits-all' approach of existing systems, which users felt was a policy failure. Clarity in textbooks was also raised as a point of concern. Users inquired about integration with e-readers and locations for testing the product, and expressed that the product would have been helpful earlier in their academic careers.


Avatar
270
30
33.3%
30
270
33.3%
Top