Should I Build It Should I Build It
11 Jun 2025
Health & Fitness

The application, named BudgetFit, aims to help individuals, ...

...particularly in emerging markets like India, eat healthy on a tight grocery budget by generating personalized meal plans based on their nutritional needs, budget constraints, and locally available foods.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

BudgetFit enters a competitive market for personalized meal planning apps. With 19 similar products already launched, there's clearly an interest in this space. However, the fact that we categorize this as a "Freemium" idea category highlights a crucial point: users appreciate these tools but are often reluctant to pay for them. The average engagement across similar products is medium, indicated by the average of 4 comments, meaning there is a need for the solution, but users need to be convinced of the value. Since we don't have specific buy or use signal, it would be best to keep in mind that this is a neutral signal since most products get little to no feedback. To succeed, BudgetFit must find a way to stand out and offer premium features or a pricing model that justifies the cost for users in emerging markets like India.

Recommendations

  1. Since you're targeting emerging markets like India, deeply understand your target users' willingness to pay. Focus on a lean approach to development and ensure the app is optimized for low-bandwidth environments. Consider offering offline functionality to cater to areas with limited internet access.
  2. Start by identifying the core user segments who find the most value in the free version of BudgetFit. This could be individuals with specific dietary needs, budget constraints, or those new to healthy eating. Focus on gathering data on their usage patterns and pain points.
  3. Based on the insights from your core users, develop premium features that address their specific needs and provide additional value. This could include advanced meal planning options, personalized coaching, or integration with local grocery delivery services. Make sure these premium features solve tangible problems that users are willing to pay for.
  4. Explore alternative monetization strategies beyond individual subscriptions. Consider partnerships with local businesses, such as grocery stores or health food providers, to offer sponsored content or exclusive deals. Think about a "B2B2C" approach, perhaps partnering with employers or NGOs focused on health and wellness initiatives in India.
  5. Implement a flexible pricing model that caters to different user segments and budget constraints. Offer tiered subscriptions with varying levels of features and support. Consider a "pay-as-you-go" option for specific services, such as personalized meal plan reviews or consultations with nutritionists.
  6. Focus on building trust and credibility within your target market. Partner with local health experts or influencers to promote BudgetFit and provide educational content on healthy eating. Highlight the app's ability to address specific health challenges in India, such as diabetes or malnutrition.
  7. Based on feedback from similar products, ensure a seamless user experience. Prioritize clear navigation, intuitive design, and fast loading times. Address any bugs or errors promptly and provide excellent customer support. Many similar products were criticized for UX issues.
  8. Actively solicit feedback from users and iterate on your product based on their suggestions. Run A/B tests on different features and pricing models to optimize your offering. Continuously monitor user engagement and retention metrics to identify areas for improvement.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape and the "Freemium" nature of the market, what specific, unique value proposition will BudgetFit offer that differentiates it from existing solutions and convinces users to upgrade to a paid plan?
  2. How will BudgetFit ensure the accuracy and cultural relevance of its meal plans, recipes, and nutritional information for users in emerging markets like India, considering the diversity of regional cuisines and dietary habits?
  3. What are the key performance indicators (KPIs) that BudgetFit will track to measure its success in achieving its mission of helping individuals eat healthy on a tight budget, and how will these KPIs inform product development and marketing decisions?

Your are here

BudgetFit enters a competitive market for personalized meal planning apps. With 19 similar products already launched, there's clearly an interest in this space. However, the fact that we categorize this as a "Freemium" idea category highlights a crucial point: users appreciate these tools but are often reluctant to pay for them. The average engagement across similar products is medium, indicated by the average of 4 comments, meaning there is a need for the solution, but users need to be convinced of the value. Since we don't have specific buy or use signal, it would be best to keep in mind that this is a neutral signal since most products get little to no feedback. To succeed, BudgetFit must find a way to stand out and offer premium features or a pricing model that justifies the cost for users in emerging markets like India.

Recommendations

  1. Since you're targeting emerging markets like India, deeply understand your target users' willingness to pay. Focus on a lean approach to development and ensure the app is optimized for low-bandwidth environments. Consider offering offline functionality to cater to areas with limited internet access.
  2. Start by identifying the core user segments who find the most value in the free version of BudgetFit. This could be individuals with specific dietary needs, budget constraints, or those new to healthy eating. Focus on gathering data on their usage patterns and pain points.
  3. Based on the insights from your core users, develop premium features that address their specific needs and provide additional value. This could include advanced meal planning options, personalized coaching, or integration with local grocery delivery services. Make sure these premium features solve tangible problems that users are willing to pay for.
  4. Explore alternative monetization strategies beyond individual subscriptions. Consider partnerships with local businesses, such as grocery stores or health food providers, to offer sponsored content or exclusive deals. Think about a "B2B2C" approach, perhaps partnering with employers or NGOs focused on health and wellness initiatives in India.
  5. Implement a flexible pricing model that caters to different user segments and budget constraints. Offer tiered subscriptions with varying levels of features and support. Consider a "pay-as-you-go" option for specific services, such as personalized meal plan reviews or consultations with nutritionists.
  6. Focus on building trust and credibility within your target market. Partner with local health experts or influencers to promote BudgetFit and provide educational content on healthy eating. Highlight the app's ability to address specific health challenges in India, such as diabetes or malnutrition.
  7. Based on feedback from similar products, ensure a seamless user experience. Prioritize clear navigation, intuitive design, and fast loading times. Address any bugs or errors promptly and provide excellent customer support. Many similar products were criticized for UX issues.
  8. Actively solicit feedback from users and iterate on your product based on their suggestions. Run A/B tests on different features and pricing models to optimize your offering. Continuously monitor user engagement and retention metrics to identify areas for improvement.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape and the "Freemium" nature of the market, what specific, unique value proposition will BudgetFit offer that differentiates it from existing solutions and convinces users to upgrade to a paid plan?
  2. How will BudgetFit ensure the accuracy and cultural relevance of its meal plans, recipes, and nutritional information for users in emerging markets like India, considering the diversity of regional cuisines and dietary habits?
  3. What are the key performance indicators (KPIs) that BudgetFit will track to measure its success in achieving its mission of helping individuals eat healthy on a tight budget, and how will these KPIs inform product development and marketing decisions?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: 25.4%
    • Positive use signal: 29.1%
    • Negative use signal: 3.7%
  • Net buy signal: -2.9%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.9%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

PennyMeal - PennyMeal: Your Personal Dietitian & Budget Saver in One App

17 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Cooking Health & Fitness

PennyMeal creates personalized meal plans based on your diet, nutrition, and budget. It adjusts recipes with real-time prices, calculates cost-per-serving, and generates grocery lists—helping you eat healthy while saving money.

Nice, useful idea, primarily US-focused, great job and best of luck.

Primarily aimed at people in the US; only shows US stores.

Avatar
10
1
100.0%
1
10
100.0%
Relevance

TastyPlan - Create your personalized meal plan

25 Jun 2023 Cooking Cookbooks Lifestyle

Generate a personalized meal plan based on your dietary preferences and restrictions. Get an automated shopping list. TastyPlan provides support from planning over shopping to cooking diverse and simple recipes. Enhance your everyday cooking experience.

TastyPlan's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team and expressing excitement about the app's potential to simplify meal planning and promote healthy eating. Users appreciate the personalized meal plans, automated shopping lists, and easy recipes. Several users highlighted the app's usefulness for those with dietary restrictions and its potential to reduce food waste. There were also suggestions for improvement, including adding more dietary options, incorporating lifestyle data, providing nutritional information, and refining the shopping list categories. A couple of users mentioned issues with vegan meal plans containing meat.

Users criticized the product for lacking diet and cuisine options, including restricted foods and healthier alternatives. There were concerns about monetization and the need for data capture for lifestyle and grocery integration. Recipe issues included lengthy preparation times, specialized equipment requirements, and the absence of options to replace generated meals. A significant error was noted where vegan meal plans incorrectly included meat. More filters and general finessing of dietary options were suggested.

Avatar
292
46
43.5%
46
292
43.5%
Relevance

youfitness - Custom meal plan your easy using IA

25 May 2024 Health & Fitness

Hey, need to revamp your diet and lose weight easily and personalized? Check out our AI-powered diet app! It creates tailor-made meal plans for you and tracks your progress with super intuitive charts. All adapted to your lifestyle, without stress.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Personalized Meal Plans to Suit Your Lifestyle

25 Nov 2023 Cooking

Hey HN, I'm Patrick a developer working on side projects beside a 9-5. I created a Site where you can create customised Meal Plans + Grocery Lists and get them automatically every Week into your Inbox.Please Check it out, any feedback is welcome!Pat

Users appreciate the concept but raise concerns about user experience and trust, questioning its differentiation from other meal plan services. They dislike the requirement to provide an email to see prices, noting the availability of free recipes elsewhere. There's confusion over whether the service is for ordering meals or obtaining recipes. Users suggest improving legibility by changing the background color and acquiring a meaningful domain name. A specific recipe error was pointed out, and the use of GPT for creating weekly plans with nutritional information is mentioned, along with a link to a similar website.

Users criticized the product for UX issues, particularly regarding trust elements and dark mode readability. The lack of differentiation from free alternatives was noted, along with the absence of visible pricing and the availability of free recipes elsewhere. The product's purpose was unclear to some, who expressed unwillingness to pay for recipes. Legibility of labels was a problem, and a specific content error was pointed out with the missing rice in the ingredients list. The product also lacks a meaningful domain name.

Avatar
19
9
-11.1%
-22.2%
9
19
11.1%
Relevance

Munchy – Automated Diet Planning Website

04 Jan 2024 Health & Fitness

I'm working on an automated diet planning app and I'd love to get your thoughts on it. You tell it about your diet and lifestyle, and it crafts personalized meal plans. It's still a work in progress - we are missing food item images in the sub-menus, and it can stumble on strict diets.We're using a donation model to keep it community-focused. That way, we are building for it to be genuinely useful for everyone here.https://buy.stripe.com/28o29a2uReDB87K4ggAs this is my first project of this kind, I'm excited to share the journey with you. If you're interested in following the progress and getting regular updates, feel free to join our Discord server:https://discord.gg/4VbseGpgI really appreciate any kind of feedback on this, and look forward to hearing it!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Foody U - Algorithm-based nutrition service

23 Mar 2023 Nutrition Health & Fitness

Foody U is an app created by nutritionist that generates personalized and unique meal plans with easy-to-make recipes using five ingredients or less. The app also offers a shopping list based on the meal plan and explains why certain meals are chosen.

The app simplifies meal planning with personalized options and ingredient limits. Users suggest improvements like meal backups, ingredient alternatives, fridge integration, and meal variations.

Avatar
75
2
100.0%
2
75
100.0%
Relevance

EatAI - Recipe recs based on prefs - digital cookbook & meal plan

27 Aug 2023 Cooking Food & Drink Health & Fitness

Let us help you create a meal plan that fits your dietary needs, restrictions, and preferences. With our personalized recipe suggestions, you'll never have to worry about finding meals that fit your lifestyle. Enjoy delicious and healthy meals!

EatAI's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, particularly for its personalized recipes and the ability to save favorites. However, multiple users reported that the 'Visit' button link is incorrect and leads to the wrong app store page (ID 163). One user inquired about the source of the recipes, questioning if they are from the internet or created specifically for the app. Fixing the visit link should be a priority.

Users criticized the Product Hunt launch due to a broken 'visit' link, which prevented them from accessing and checking out the app. Additionally, a user suggested incorporating a feature to save favorite recipes for improved user experience.

Avatar
81
6
16.7%
6
81
16.7%
Relevance

MealPlanner - Meals perfectly tailored for your dietary requirements

05 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Health & Fitness

Introducing MealPlanner, the revolutionary app that combines the power of AI to discover unique and tasty meal options perfectly tailored to your dietary requirements. - AI-Driven Meal Planning - Meal Planning Assistant - In-app Shopping List

Users expressed excitement and gratitude for MealPlanner's innovative AI features. A common request was for the development of an Android version of the app to broaden its accessibility.

The feedback primarily revolves around expanding MealPlanner's functionality to cater to specific health conditions, suggesting a need for more tailored dietary planning features.

Avatar
62
2
50.0%
2
62
50.0%
Relevance

A web app to track your grocery expenses and nutrition

03 Jul 2024 Health & Fitness

Hello HN,I've been working on a tool during the weekend to help make cheaper and healthier grocery choices. Currently, it only gives me simple stats on my grocery bill and some general comments on how you can improve your shopping next time. (No signup/email needed.)I believe that healthy food is something cooked in your kitchen, but it also takes a lot of time.So, I started by building an Airbnb-like platform where people can find local cooks (not just experienced chefs) to do meal prep in their homes. After working 9 months on it, I realized it was hard to get people on the platform. So, I thought I should build something people can use for free to create some awareness around it.As usual, I have many features in mind that I would like to implement, but I would love to hear some feedback. I have 3 friends using it regularly, but it might still break. If you care, please try it out, sign up or hit me up on X.Thanks, Aman

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I built an app to simplify meal prep with automatic macro calculations

09 Nov 2024 Cooking Health & Fitness

I created an app called Flavora to help people make meal prepping easier, especially for those with specific nutritional goals. With Flavora, you can generate meal plans based on the ingredients you have and your dietary preferences, and it automatically calculates macros for each meal.I built this because I wanted a streamlined way to meal prep without using spreadsheets. It’s saved me time, reduced my grocery budget, and taken the guesswork out of my daily meals. No subscriptions or account needed—Flavora works with a point system where each recipe generated uses one point, keeping it affordable for everyone.I’d love your feedback and suggestions!

Users appreciate the app for easy meal prepping with nutritional goals. However, there are issues with signing up on mobile and unclear points introduction. iPhone users face specific problems and suggest changing the term 'win' to 'earn.'

Users criticized the product for having a keyboard that covers the signup process, scammy text, and unclear points. Additionally, it was described as janky on iPhone.

Avatar
1
3
-66.7%
-33.3%
3
1
Top