Should I Build It Should I Build It
11 Jun 2025
Pets

Dog photo editor that makes your dog's beautiful and fixes old age ...

...belmishes

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for a dog photo editor that beautifies your dog and fixes old age blemishes falls into a crowded space. We found 19 similar products, indicating high competition. The category is considered a 'Swamp' because many mediocre solutions exist and it's hard to stand out. While individual launches receive some positive feedback (enthusiasm, excitement) , the general engagement is low with an average of only 3 comments per product. The lack of strong net use and net buy signals further reinforces the 'Swamp' designation. You need to offer something REALLY different to succeed, or you will likely struggle to make money and the underlying IDEA CATEGORY indicates that you probably shouldn't even be building this. Based on the 'Swamp' idea category, you may want to reconsider this project.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, deeply research why existing dog photo editing solutions haven't fully captured the market. Understand their limitations and user frustrations. This will help you identify potential gaps and opportunities for differentiation. Look closely at the products mentioned in the similar products section. What are people excited about and where does that enthusiasm drop off?
  2. If you decide to move forward, identify a very specific niche within the dog photo editing space. For example, focus on a particular breed, specific types of blemishes (e.g., only eye boogers), or a unique artistic style (e.g., watercolor portraits). Carving out a niche will help you attract a dedicated user base.
  3. Instead of building a standalone app, consider developing plugins or tools for existing photo editing software or platforms that cater to pet owners. This allows you to tap into an established user base and avoid the challenges of building a product from scratch. See if you can make tools for other apps using their API or other integrations. One of the similar product criticisms was that Photoshop was too complicated, see if you can simplify the process.
  4. Explore adjacent problems that might be more promising. Instead of focusing solely on photo editing, consider offering services like creating custom pet merchandise (e.g., mugs, t-shirts) using the edited photos. You need to look at other value drivers if you're going to make this work.
  5. Given the challenges in the 'Swamp' category, it may be wise to save your energy and resources for a more promising opportunity. Explore other ideas that align with your skills and passions but have less competition and more potential for growth. Don't get stuck on just the first idea.
  6. Review the user feedback from similar products, noting both the positive comments (e.g., enthusiasm, fulfilling a need) and criticisms (e.g., output quality concerns, CORS errors). Address these pain points in your own approach to stand a chance of getting above the noise. Consider that the most successful product had 21 comments, try to emulate what they did right and ask what the others did wrong.
  7. Consider integrating AI-powered features to streamline the editing process. This could include automatic blemish removal, background enhancement, or artistic style transfer. AI could increase speed while reducing user friction and improve overall effectiveness. But be careful not to produce the same old same old.

Questions

  1. What specific unmet needs or pain points do dog owners have when it comes to editing their pet photos that existing solutions are not addressing?
  2. How can you create a dog photo editing experience that is significantly more engaging and user-friendly than existing options, given the low average engagement of similar products?
  3. Given the potential for 'wasted credits' due to imperfect AI output noted in similar products, how will you ensure a consistent and satisfactory user experience, especially when relying on AI-powered features?

Your are here

Your idea for a dog photo editor that beautifies your dog and fixes old age blemishes falls into a crowded space. We found 19 similar products, indicating high competition. The category is considered a 'Swamp' because many mediocre solutions exist and it's hard to stand out. While individual launches receive some positive feedback (enthusiasm, excitement) , the general engagement is low with an average of only 3 comments per product. The lack of strong net use and net buy signals further reinforces the 'Swamp' designation. You need to offer something REALLY different to succeed, or you will likely struggle to make money and the underlying IDEA CATEGORY indicates that you probably shouldn't even be building this. Based on the 'Swamp' idea category, you may want to reconsider this project.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, deeply research why existing dog photo editing solutions haven't fully captured the market. Understand their limitations and user frustrations. This will help you identify potential gaps and opportunities for differentiation. Look closely at the products mentioned in the similar products section. What are people excited about and where does that enthusiasm drop off?
  2. If you decide to move forward, identify a very specific niche within the dog photo editing space. For example, focus on a particular breed, specific types of blemishes (e.g., only eye boogers), or a unique artistic style (e.g., watercolor portraits). Carving out a niche will help you attract a dedicated user base.
  3. Instead of building a standalone app, consider developing plugins or tools for existing photo editing software or platforms that cater to pet owners. This allows you to tap into an established user base and avoid the challenges of building a product from scratch. See if you can make tools for other apps using their API or other integrations. One of the similar product criticisms was that Photoshop was too complicated, see if you can simplify the process.
  4. Explore adjacent problems that might be more promising. Instead of focusing solely on photo editing, consider offering services like creating custom pet merchandise (e.g., mugs, t-shirts) using the edited photos. You need to look at other value drivers if you're going to make this work.
  5. Given the challenges in the 'Swamp' category, it may be wise to save your energy and resources for a more promising opportunity. Explore other ideas that align with your skills and passions but have less competition and more potential for growth. Don't get stuck on just the first idea.
  6. Review the user feedback from similar products, noting both the positive comments (e.g., enthusiasm, fulfilling a need) and criticisms (e.g., output quality concerns, CORS errors). Address these pain points in your own approach to stand a chance of getting above the noise. Consider that the most successful product had 21 comments, try to emulate what they did right and ask what the others did wrong.
  7. Consider integrating AI-powered features to streamline the editing process. This could include automatic blemish removal, background enhancement, or artistic style transfer. AI could increase speed while reducing user friction and improve overall effectiveness. But be careful not to produce the same old same old.

Questions

  1. What specific unmet needs or pain points do dog owners have when it comes to editing their pet photos that existing solutions are not addressing?
  2. How can you create a dog photo editing experience that is significantly more engaging and user-friendly than existing options, given the low average engagement of similar products?
  3. Given the potential for 'wasted credits' due to imperfect AI output noted in similar products, how will you ensure a consistent and satisfactory user experience, especially when relying on AI-powered features?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 19.5%
    • Positive use signal: 20.5%
    • Negative use signal: 1.0%
  • Net buy signal: 2.5%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.5%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

FotoFix - The easiest way to fix old photos or beautify new ones

17 Mar 2023 Artificial Intelligence Photography

Introducing FotoFix, an AI-powered tool to effortlessly restore old photos or beautify new ones. FotoFix makes it easy for anyone to achieve stunning results with just a few clicks.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users expressing enthusiasm with comments like "Super idea" and "nice." One user expressed relief and gratitude by saying "Finally! Thank you!", indicating that the launch fulfilled a need or expectation.

Avatar
72
3
3
72
Relevance

PetPet - Turn pet photos into pet portraits using AI

09 Jul 2024 Artificial Intelligence Art Pets

Effortlessly use our AI generation tool to turn your dog's photo into a watercolor portrait 🪄. Stunning styles include popular illustrations, watercolors🎨, oil paintings, and more✨. Simply upload a dog photo, select an AI preset, and export it as a portrait.

Users found the anthropomorphic style of the portraits hilarious and adorable. The full commercial license for the portraits was appreciated, enabling free usage. The skydiving style portrait was particularly well-received as fun, quirky, and a hit among users' friends.

Avatar
7
3
66.7%
3
7
66.7%
Relevance

Simple Fix of Blurry Photo

01 Apr 2024 Design Tools Artificial Intelligence Photography

I had some old photos and trying to make them look better with photoshop but the actions are too complicated. Then look out for some AI opensource project which helps to nail it. So I make this on public for free sharing. Don't abuse it with inappropriate image.

Users find Photoshop too complicated and appreciate the use of AI for photo enhancement. The product received positive feedback for its effectiveness.

The Photoshop actions are considered too complicated by users.

Avatar
2
2
2
2
Relevance

Generative AI photos of your dog

13 Aug 2023 Artificial Intelligence Pets

Hi I'm Devin!I made a site where you can get AI generated photos of your dog! Upload 5 photos of your pet and get 20 photos of your chosen style to choose from.Working on adding new styles so if you have any ideas happy to do something custom!I've given several of these to friends and family and they make great gifts for the dog lovers in your life.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I have created a cheaper pet portrait generator

08 Jul 2024 Pets

Over the past few years, I have spent over 1000 dollars on Etsy to commission pet portraits for myself and my friends. It's really expensive and takes a long time to deliver, so I created a tool for making pet portraits (petpet.ai) by myself.I spent a total of 3 months to complete it independently, trained 12 different styles of portrait painting, and support custom canvas color and text.petpet.ai includes several parts: a.Pet Portrait Generation - Upload a clear front photo of your pet, and the program will intelligently create a pet portrait painting based on the chosen style. b. 12 types of portrait styles - including the currently popular modern illustration style, modern watercolor style, detailed oil painting style, anthropomorphic general style, photo-realistic style and so on... c. Art Photo Editor - Can customize the canvas color and write pets' names on the portrait with beautiful fonts.I've put a lot of passion into this and hope to get some positive feedback. Much appreciated!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

PawFoto - AI Photoshoot For Your Pawsome Pets

23 Jun 2024 Artificial Intelligence Photography Pets

PawFoto generates the most realistic AI pet photos ever. It is an AI photos generator that can create furfect photos of your pet in different settings. Simply upload your pet's photos to generate them today.

Users overwhelmingly congratulate Yifan on the launch, wishing him and the product success. Many believe pet owners will love it, with some anticipating viral potential. One user specifically praised the fast shipping speed and work ethic. There's excitement about using the product, particularly from a user who recently got a new dog for this purpose. A question regarding breed accuracy was raised, as well as future styles. One commenter mentions being inspired to get a pet. Photography enthusiasts are appreciative of the photo and portrait photography.

Users have noted that the product requires an editor, as not all photos produced meet desired expectations.

Avatar
72
21
9.5%
4.8%
21
72
9.5%
4.8%
Relevance

Phopet - Upload photos of your pet and receive professional photos

14 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence Photography

Make your pet the star of their own photo album! Phopet is the first AI app exclusively designed for pets, transforming everyday pet photos into stunning, studio-quality images. Simply upload a few pictures, and let our AI create jaw-dropping, memorable photos

Users express excitement and a strong desire to try the product. There's a suggestion to include testimonials and real-life examples to further enhance its appeal.

Users express concerns regarding output quality when prompts are not perfect and how this affects credit usage. The criticism centers around the potential for wasted credits on unsatisfactory results due to imperfect user input.

Avatar
13
2
100.0%
2
13
100.0%
Relevance

PetAI - Generate AI Photos for Your Pets

26 Sep 2024 Design Tools Artificial Intelligence

PetAI is an innovative AI-powered pet photo application that brings a new dimension to your furry friend's portraits. With our cutting-edge technology, you can now generate unique and imaginative AI-enhanced photos of your beloved pets.

PetAI is being lauded as a fun, creative, fantastic, innovative, and heartwarming tool. Users highlight its ability to generate personalized pet portraits and open new creative possibilities.

Avatar
12
2
50.0%
2
12
50.0%
Relevance

Petsy AI - Transform pet photos into stunning portrait masterpieces

13 Mar 2024 Artificial Intelligence Photography Pets

Petsy.AI, an innovative AI startup recently recognized with grants from Microsoft and Google. Our mission is to revolutionize pet portraiture by transforming beloved pet photos into stunning digital masterpieces using cutting-edge generative AI technology.

Petsy AI's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback. Users congratulated the team and expressed excitement about the product's potential and future development. A new user found the app useful and complimented the launch.

Avatar
79
3
66.7%
3
79
66.7%
Relevance

ThePetPainting - Turn photos of your pets into art using AI, free

09 Jan 2023 Artificial Intelligence Pets Dogs

Our simple web app allows users to turn photos of their pets into art using AI. After uploading 12-20 photos, users get back 90+ digital art pieces of their pet in a range of styles. The service is completely free!

The product launch is congratulated and considered fantastic. A user has uploaded dog photos and is awaiting the results.

Avatar
28
2
50.0%
2
28
50.0%
Relevance

Pet Lens AI - AI Photographer For Your Pet

19 Sep 2024 Photography Pets Tech

Get beautiful photos of your pet effortlessly with an AI Photographer! Skip the hassle of blurry photos and mediocre backgrounds. Let your pet travel the world and new experiences!

Users are excited about the product's potential. One user is looking forward to using it for their pet's Instagram account, while another anticipates using it during the holidays. A specific benefit highlighted is the device's ability to take pictures of a rabbit in various locations, expanding beyond the confines of an apartment. First impressions are positive.

Avatar
21
3
100.0%
3
21
100.0%
Relevance

DrawnBy.AI - Your dog

16 Aug 2023 Artificial Intelligence Art Dogs

DrawnBy.AI uses AI to make the world a happier place, one dog owner at a time. Upload photos of your dog to our website, then AI generates artistic masterpieces. We're dog lovers and AI enthusiasts bringing smiles to the faces of our customers.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Many users congratulated the team and wished them good luck. Several commenters expressed enthusiasm, with one highlighting a dog-related aspect. One user wants a similar product for cats. The general sentiment indicates excitement and appreciation for the launch.

Avatar
107
11
18.2%
9.1%
11
107
18.2%
9.1%
Relevance

AI Pet Portraits - AI generated pet portraits for your furry friend

28 Mar 2023 Design Tools Art Pets

Get your AI generated pet portrait for free. Prompt your own personalized model to create any portrait you want for your furry friend instantly 🐶🐈

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with one user describing the product as brilliant. A question was raised regarding its advantages compared to DALL-E, indicating interest in its unique value proposition.

Avatar
75
2
2
75
Relevance

Custom Dog Art based your dog photo - Unique Custom Dog Art & Personalized Pet Portraits

05 Jul 2024 Art Pets Dogs

Get your custom dog art printed on canvas. Many sizes available. Email your dog photo to Design@erosner.com and we will start turning your pup into pop art for stunning results.

Users express strong positive sentiment towards the pop art pet portrait idea, describing it as awesome and unique. A key point of interest is the turnaround time for the portraits. There's also a question regarding the available size options.

The primary criticism expressed is disappointment that the Product Hunt launch was not featured.

Avatar
12
3
3
12
Top