I want to build an open source headless CMS focused on ease of use ...

...and integration with popular frameworks

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your open-source headless CMS focused on ease of use and integration. We found 19 similar products, indicating high competition but also validating the market demand. The 'Freemium' category fits well here, as people generally appreciate and use such tools, but converting them to paying customers can be tricky. While there isn't explicit 'use' or 'buy' signal data available from similar product launches, a medium engagement level suggests interest in the space. Based on the success of products such as Strapi the headless CMS market is growing. To succeed, you'll need to offer a compelling value proposition that differentiates you from existing solutions and entices users to upgrade to a paid version.

Recommendations

  1. Given the number of competitors, begin by deeply understanding their strengths and weaknesses. Many users criticized Vrite for poor documentation, Postiva for a lack of clear guidance, and Weightless CMS for Google tracking. Focus on superior user experience and transparency in your offering.
  2. Open source does not mean no cost. Plan how you can generate revenue, even if the base product is free. Offer premium features like advanced analytics, dedicated support, or integrations with other services that appeal to power users or enterprise clients.
  3. As the 'Freemium' category suggests, identify the users who get the most value from the free version. Understand their needs and pain points, then create premium features that address these issues specifically. Target teams over individuals if possible, as they often have larger budgets and are more willing to pay for collaboration and management features.
  4. Based on commentary from similar products, it's clear that a good deployment process is crucial. Focus on making the deployment process as painless as possible from day one.
  5. Offer personalized help or consulting services to larger clients who need assistance with setup, customization, or integration. This can be a valuable revenue stream and a way to build stronger relationships with your users.
  6. Implement A/B testing and collect feedback on your pricing plans early on. Experiment with different approaches, such as usage-based pricing, feature-based tiers, or subscription models, to find what resonates best with your target audience.
  7. Given that users look forward to future updates, make sure your roadmap includes highly requested features, and make it visible and easy to contribute to.
  8. Proactively create high-quality documentation and tutorials. Based on the feedback from competitors, this is a must. Address common pain points and provide clear, concise instructions for getting started and using advanced features. Consider video tutorials and interactive demos.

Questions

  1. Considering the challenges faced by other open-source CMS projects, what specific features or integrations will make your CMS stand out and attract a dedicated user base?
  2. How will you balance the need for ease of use with the flexibility and customization options that developers expect from a headless CMS?
  3. Given the difficulty in converting free users to paying customers, what specific value-added services or features will you offer to incentivize users to upgrade to a premium plan, and how will you market these offerings effectively?

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your open-source headless CMS focused on ease of use and integration. We found 19 similar products, indicating high competition but also validating the market demand. The 'Freemium' category fits well here, as people generally appreciate and use such tools, but converting them to paying customers can be tricky. While there isn't explicit 'use' or 'buy' signal data available from similar product launches, a medium engagement level suggests interest in the space. Based on the success of products such as Strapi the headless CMS market is growing. To succeed, you'll need to offer a compelling value proposition that differentiates you from existing solutions and entices users to upgrade to a paid version.

Recommendations

  1. Given the number of competitors, begin by deeply understanding their strengths and weaknesses. Many users criticized Vrite for poor documentation, Postiva for a lack of clear guidance, and Weightless CMS for Google tracking. Focus on superior user experience and transparency in your offering.
  2. Open source does not mean no cost. Plan how you can generate revenue, even if the base product is free. Offer premium features like advanced analytics, dedicated support, or integrations with other services that appeal to power users or enterprise clients.
  3. As the 'Freemium' category suggests, identify the users who get the most value from the free version. Understand their needs and pain points, then create premium features that address these issues specifically. Target teams over individuals if possible, as they often have larger budgets and are more willing to pay for collaboration and management features.
  4. Based on commentary from similar products, it's clear that a good deployment process is crucial. Focus on making the deployment process as painless as possible from day one.
  5. Offer personalized help or consulting services to larger clients who need assistance with setup, customization, or integration. This can be a valuable revenue stream and a way to build stronger relationships with your users.
  6. Implement A/B testing and collect feedback on your pricing plans early on. Experiment with different approaches, such as usage-based pricing, feature-based tiers, or subscription models, to find what resonates best with your target audience.
  7. Given that users look forward to future updates, make sure your roadmap includes highly requested features, and make it visible and easy to contribute to.
  8. Proactively create high-quality documentation and tutorials. Based on the feedback from competitors, this is a must. Address common pain points and provide clear, concise instructions for getting started and using advanced features. Consider video tutorials and interactive demos.

Questions

  1. Considering the challenges faced by other open-source CMS projects, what specific features or integrations will make your CMS stand out and attract a dedicated user base?
  2. How will you balance the need for ease of use with the flexibility and customization options that developers expect from a headless CMS?
  3. Given the difficulty in converting free users to paying customers, what specific value-added services or features will you offer to incentivize users to upgrade to a premium plan, and how will you market these offerings effectively?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 11.9%
    • Positive use signal: 16.1%
    • Negative use signal: 4.2%
  • Net buy signal: -1.3%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.8%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.1%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Dynamic headless CMS with built-in CDP, AB testing and personalization

24 Sep 2024 Developer Tools

Hey HN,I'm a developer and long-time OSS contributor. Over the years, I've implemented tons of headless CMSs to give product and marketing teams more autonomy. But there's always been a gap with CMSs when it comes to user interfaces.I kept running into the same issues: poor developer experience, bad performance, no support for dynamic content, and needing vendors for AB testing or personalization, which just gets messy and expensive.Versioning? One change and things break or need manual fixes. Accessing your own data? Good luck unless you're ready to pay extra.So, I built a content API with an initial focus on React and Next.js. No vendors, no component changes. It comes with automatic versioning, TypeScript type generation, built-in A/B testing, analytics, and personalization. Think of it like `fetch` but with superpowers: it understands user context and delivers different content to different users.Most solutions are way too expensive for startups, so we've got a generous forever-free plan. I'm also thinking of expanding it to early-stage companies with more traffic.I'd love to hear any feedback, especially from developers!


Avatar
22
22
Relevance

I’m building open-source headless CMS for technical content

In the last few years I've been doing a lot of technical writing, both for my own programming blog and others, and I've noticed there is a lack of good tools for this kind of writing.Whether that was a programming blog post or documentation, I always had to move back an forth between different editors, and sometimes even other apps for content management and the actual content publication. A lot of copy-pasting, and wasted time.Based on this experience I decided to try and build a tool that could provide a good experience for this kind of content from writing to publishing. This (I call it Vrite) ended up being essentially a headless CMS, but optimized for technical content and a pretty unique one overall, I'd say.I tried to combine what can be seen as 3 separate products into one: - WYSIWYG editor (with the addition of code-specific tooling like code editor or formatter) - Kanban dashboard (inspired by my experience of tools like Trello used in larger technical content teams to manage content production process) - The actual headless CMS (content delivery via API, integrations, etc.)Most recently I decided to open-source it and see if there's any interest in such a tool. Right now the primary focus was my personal use-case (kind-of "promotional" technical writing seen in programming and start-up blogs), but I think, with more customization, something like this could extend to the documentation space and make writing and managing docs a lot easier.Let me know what do you think about this.

Users provided mixed feedback on Vrite, with some appreciating the UI/UX and content service but questioning its market fit, suitability for technical writing, and terminology like 'headless'. There were suggestions for improvements in project management, editor features, and integrations. The need for better documentation, pricing details, and self-hosting information was highlighted. Criticisms included confusion over the GUI in a headless CMS and the complexity of CCS. Users also discussed alternatives like Markdown, static site generators, and docs-as-code, and mentioned the success of Stripe's documentation system.

Users criticized Vrite for poor documentation, limited collaboration due to personal kanban, and a lack of features for non-technical writers. Design choices were seen as disruptive to user flow. Issues with project management, editor flexibility, and image handling were noted. The use of 'headless' was deemed misleading, with confusion over the GUI's role. The API's lack of a management interface, unclear image/table support, and subpar default Swagger UI were also criticized. Jekyll's missing features, unclear pricing/self-hosting, and resistance from developers were mentioned. Doubts about market fit and the restrictive nature of a headless CMS were expressed, alongside specific technical and sign-up issues.


Avatar
89
37
-2.7%
-5.4%
37
89
8.1%
Relevance

TerminusCMS – Headless CMS for Devs

15 Feb 2023 GitHub Developer Tools

Existing headless CMS tools are mostly making it up as they go along - starting with the idea of ‘I want to build a company that delivers a headless CMS’ and then quickly slapping a bunch of technologies together and ending up with a pile of JSONs floating around a MongoDB or another similar frankenstein. As we’d already built the document graph data layer from the ground up, we could properly integrate the CMS features to give a seamless developer experience. We are never going to send you to a screen that says, ‘TerminusCRM requires NodeJS version 10+ and a Mongo database’. It is all contained in one in-memory, highly compressed data management system that we designed and built for this specific purpose.A few of the other offerings are just headless markdown backed by git - which is actually a good idea, but comes with the capacity and performance limitations that git implies.Why not have a highly performant document graph content management system that incorporates the most important concepts from git in the data layer? All the version control features that content needs (clone, push, pull, branch, revert, merge) and are highly awkward in other systems. We also thought that GraphQL was the obvious data manipulation choice for content, but found weak implementations wherever we looked. For TerminusCMS, we’ve implemented a suite of features which allows you to query a TerminusCMS project using GraphQL in such a way that deep linking can be discovered. We can use path queries with GraphQL.To summarize our market thoughts - it seems that devs want:- Deploy anywhere open-source - Dev-first in memory, highly compressed, scalable and fast content management so you can build complex and fully featured web apps of every shape and size - Git-like features to help with permissions and version control (and - crucially - merge) - Best-in-class GraphQL implementationAnd there was nothing offering that mix until we released TerminusCMS.TerminusCMS is a content platform that sits at the convergence of content and knowledge. It is a model-driven, API-first approach to content management. With TerminusCMS you can use your data as content. The data employed in content has meanings associated with it, and because that content is well structured, the content can also be used as if it were data — in fact, that content is data. TerminusCMS is structured like Git, so you get all the git-like features for your content engine. History, change management, branching, non-linear development, easy backups, distributed development, and more. You can enrich your content with semantics which can give you the ability to personalize content and build superior recommender and AI/ML systems.Content curation needs change requests: you need to be able to add a new translation, or new content in a branch, which is viewable as an entire site, but which only goes into production when you "merge to main".TerminusCMS gives devs a powerful way to define schema, query, deliver content and assets to front end. It has schema-as-code; is standards-based for interoperability; has an extremely fast publishing API; and provides workflows made by way of content and network model, not wired into product itself. It give editors a way to manage content automatically so that devs don't need to do much to support them. You can use TerminusCMS to build your complex app, or to manage your organization knowledge.TerminusCMS is open-source all the way down, so if we vanish or piss you off, you can recover and continue.The business is cloud hosting and enterprise delivery, which we hope can keep the wolf from the door. It is freemium with a generous free tier and easily cloned examples, so take a look.[1] https://terminusdb.com/ [2] https://github.com/GavinMendelGleason/blog/blob/main/entries/content_revolution.md

Clickable links provided.


Avatar
9
1
1
9
Relevance

NodeHive – Eco-Conscious Headless CMS

02 Oct 2023 Developer Tools

We are excited to announce NodeHive – The Eco-Conscious Headless CMS.See it in action https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JzQrEc5RJbI.A Glimpse into Our Journey: We're NETNODE, a team that has been crafting websites primarily with Drupal CMS for years. As the digital ecosystem evolved with powerful frameworks like NextJS, Svelte, and more, we transitioned to decoupled solutions, gravitating particularly towards NextJS for the frontend.In our exploration of potential backends, we evaluated CMS systems like Strapi, Sanity, Directus, and others. While each had its merits, we recognized the unmatched open-source flexibility of Drupal and its extensive module ecosystem. This insight drove us to develop NodeHive, combining Drupal's strengths with our vision for a state-of-the-art Headless CMS.Meet NodeHive: At its core, NodeHive is an API-first (GraphQL, JSON-Api, Rest), Open-Source, Headless/Composable CMS with enterprise-grade features. It's built atop Drupal and integrates seamlessly with any Drupal codebase: https://www.drupal.org/project/nodehive_core.What Makes NodeHive Eco-Conscious? Discover our commitment to a sustainable digital future: https://www.nodehiveapp.com/eco-consciousAnother Headless CMS? Here's Why: While the Headless CMS arena is bustling with contenders, Drupal lacks a definitive "go-to" solution for decoupled designs. NodeHive aspires to fill that void, aiming to be the premier Drupal Headless CMS.Creating with NodeHive is not just efficient but also delightful. If you're venturing into headless solutions, NodeHive deserves your attention.Join Our Mission: We invite you to partner with us in sculpting digital experiences that don't merely innovate but also tread lightly on our planet.Cheers to a future that's not just tech-forward, but also eco-forward!


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Strapi 5 - Headless CMS designed for customization and performance

This new version introduces major improvements including new content management features and a significant architecture refactoring to boost performance, scalability, and developer experience.

Strapi 5's launch is met with widespread congratulations and excitement, particularly for its improved developer experience (DX), performance enhancements, and new features. Many users laud Strapi as the best CMS. Several comments highlight the game-changing nature of the new version and its potential impact on various projects, including community initiatives and content management systems like Kestra. A user hopes V5 has improved deployment, since V4 was hard to deploy.

The primary criticism is that deploying the V4 version is proving to be troublesome for users. This appears to be the only issue raised in the provided feedback.


Avatar
336
20
40.0%
20
336
40.0%
Relevance

Maple CMS - Headless CMS with AI superpowers

MapleCMS is a powerful and sweet headless CMS with AI superpowers. Effortlessly create, manage, and integrate your content anywhere with zero learning curve and seamless code generation for any stack!

The launch received positive feedback, with users highlighting the benefits of a Headless CMS, praising its liberating nature and retention of design freedom. The AI integration was also well-received. Additionally, the product was recognized as a valuable tool for NextJS developers.


Avatar
22
2
2
22
Relevance

Postiva - Easy-to-use headless CMS

12 Jul 2024 SaaS API

Postiva is a SaaS platform tailored to the needs of content creators. With advanced API and SDK support, it simplifies content management, creation, and distribution processes, enabling you to communicate more effectively with your audience.

Postiva's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users repeatedly congratulating the launch and praising the clean, user-friendly UI. Many are excited about its potential for content creation workflows and improved audience engagement. The analytics dashboard, API, and SDK support were also highlighted as valuable features. Some users inquired about Postiva's differentiating factor and its purpose, while others asked about adding new members. Users look forward to future updates.

Users express concerns about Postiva's differentiation from established headless CMS platforms. There is also criticism around the lack of clear guidance within the app, specifically regarding making a first post. Instructions on how to add new members are also reportedly missing, leading to confusion and a potentially difficult onboarding experience.


Avatar
153
11
18.2%
11
153
18.2%
Relevance

Weightless CMS for Side Projects

28 May 2024 Developer Tools

Users appreciate the design but have concerns about Google tracking. They are inquiring about the backend and repository availability, and are requesting an about page or more information. Some users are comparing the product to CouchDB.

Users criticized the product for explicit and implicit Google tracking, and the lack of an about page or accessible repository.


Avatar
12
4
4
12
Top