Should I Build It Should I Build It
20 May 2025
No-Code

Workflow generator for make.com and n8n. Users write text, and get ...

...workflow as JSON output

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

You're entering a market with a good number of similar products (n_matches = 11), suggesting that there's a real need for workflow automation tools, specifically those that cater to platforms like Make.com and n8n. The engagement level is medium, with an average of 9 comments per similar product, indicating that users are actively discussing and exploring these tools. Given the "Freemium" idea category, you need to recognize that while people appreciate using these types of tools, converting them to paying customers can be challenging. You'll need to clearly define your value proposition and how it differs from existing solutions, especially in terms of features or integrations that justify a premium offering. Don't be afraid to build and put yourself out there, but make sure you have a plan in place to acquire those first paying customers.

Recommendations

  1. Start by identifying the user segments that derive the most value from the free versions of Make.com and n8n workflow automation. Conduct user interviews and analyze how they currently use these platforms to pinpoint pain points and opportunities for improvement. This will allow you to tailor your text-to-JSON workflow generator to their specific needs and use cases.
  2. Based on your user research, create premium features that cater to these specific segments. This could involve adding advanced text processing capabilities, supporting more complex workflow structures, offering enhanced error handling, or providing integrations with other popular services. Emphasize features that significantly enhance productivity and justify the cost of a premium subscription.
  3. Explore pricing models that cater to teams rather than individuals. This could involve offering collaborative features, role-based access control, and team-specific reporting. Selling to teams can increase your revenue per user and provide a more sustainable business model. Consider incorporating features tailored to team collaboration, addressing criticisms from similar products about limitations in custom automations.
  4. Offer personalized help or consulting services to users who need assistance with complex workflows. This can be a valuable revenue stream and a way to build stronger relationships with your customers. Focus on providing tailored solutions that address their specific needs and challenges. Consider incorporating direct support based on the criticism that some products lack AI for user input.
  5. Implement A/B testing with different pricing approaches and feature sets with small groups of users. Analyze the data to determine which pricing models and features resonate most with your target audience. This will help you optimize your product and pricing strategy for maximum revenue. Address claims that pricing is too high by offering flexible plans or value-added services.
  6. Given the discussion around the need for a sandbox environment in similar products, prioritize developing a sandbox feature that allows users to test their workflows in a safe and isolated environment. This will mitigate the risk of errors and provide a more confident user experience.
  7. Showcase clear workflow demonstrations and use cases on your homepage to address the confusion some users experience with similar products. Focus on highlighting the ease of use and the efficiency gains that your text-to-JSON workflow generator provides. Consider also creating comparison documentation to LangChain as was requested in the similar product discussions.

Questions

  1. Given the concerns about data privacy expressed in the feedback for similar products, how will you ensure that your text-to-JSON workflow generator adheres to the highest standards of data security and compliance, especially for users who prefer self-deployment?
  2. How will you differentiate your product in a market with many similar products in order to avoid the user comments that the claims that your product makes needs some substantiation?
  3. Considering the reported errors encountered by users of similar workflow automation tools, what specific measures will you take to ensure the reliability and stability of your text-to-JSON workflow generator, especially when handling complex or large-scale workflows?

Your are here

You're entering a market with a good number of similar products (n_matches = 11), suggesting that there's a real need for workflow automation tools, specifically those that cater to platforms like Make.com and n8n. The engagement level is medium, with an average of 9 comments per similar product, indicating that users are actively discussing and exploring these tools. Given the "Freemium" idea category, you need to recognize that while people appreciate using these types of tools, converting them to paying customers can be challenging. You'll need to clearly define your value proposition and how it differs from existing solutions, especially in terms of features or integrations that justify a premium offering. Don't be afraid to build and put yourself out there, but make sure you have a plan in place to acquire those first paying customers.

Recommendations

  1. Start by identifying the user segments that derive the most value from the free versions of Make.com and n8n workflow automation. Conduct user interviews and analyze how they currently use these platforms to pinpoint pain points and opportunities for improvement. This will allow you to tailor your text-to-JSON workflow generator to their specific needs and use cases.
  2. Based on your user research, create premium features that cater to these specific segments. This could involve adding advanced text processing capabilities, supporting more complex workflow structures, offering enhanced error handling, or providing integrations with other popular services. Emphasize features that significantly enhance productivity and justify the cost of a premium subscription.
  3. Explore pricing models that cater to teams rather than individuals. This could involve offering collaborative features, role-based access control, and team-specific reporting. Selling to teams can increase your revenue per user and provide a more sustainable business model. Consider incorporating features tailored to team collaboration, addressing criticisms from similar products about limitations in custom automations.
  4. Offer personalized help or consulting services to users who need assistance with complex workflows. This can be a valuable revenue stream and a way to build stronger relationships with your customers. Focus on providing tailored solutions that address their specific needs and challenges. Consider incorporating direct support based on the criticism that some products lack AI for user input.
  5. Implement A/B testing with different pricing approaches and feature sets with small groups of users. Analyze the data to determine which pricing models and features resonate most with your target audience. This will help you optimize your product and pricing strategy for maximum revenue. Address claims that pricing is too high by offering flexible plans or value-added services.
  6. Given the discussion around the need for a sandbox environment in similar products, prioritize developing a sandbox feature that allows users to test their workflows in a safe and isolated environment. This will mitigate the risk of errors and provide a more confident user experience.
  7. Showcase clear workflow demonstrations and use cases on your homepage to address the confusion some users experience with similar products. Focus on highlighting the ease of use and the efficiency gains that your text-to-JSON workflow generator provides. Consider also creating comparison documentation to LangChain as was requested in the similar product discussions.

Questions

  1. Given the concerns about data privacy expressed in the feedback for similar products, how will you ensure that your text-to-JSON workflow generator adheres to the highest standards of data security and compliance, especially for users who prefer self-deployment?
  2. How will you differentiate your product in a market with many similar products in order to avoid the user comments that the claims that your product makes needs some substantiation?
  3. Considering the reported errors encountered by users of similar workflow automation tools, what specific measures will you take to ensure the reliability and stability of your text-to-JSON workflow generator, especially when handling complex or large-scale workflows?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 11
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 9
  • Net use signal: 13.8%
    • Positive use signal: 15.5%
    • Negative use signal: 1.7%
  • Net buy signal: -0.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.3%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.7%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Nekton – Automate your workflows with AI

28 Apr 2023 Productivity Developer Tools

Show HN: Nekton - Automate your workflows with AIHi HN,I'm Alex, founder of Nekton. You can use this service to automate your workflows. First, you can describe your workflow as text steps, and then Nekton AI will convert them to code and run it in the cloud.The code can make network calls and integrate with different external APIs and services.Nekton is in early access, but you already can create step-by-step checklists, mix together manual and automated tasks in a single workflow, collect user input with forms, and share the workflow with your teammates.We have a sample workflow that you can play around with after signup.Let me know what you think!

Users are inquiring about the code generation language used and reporting issues with importing npm packages.

The main criticism is that users are encountering errors while using the product or service.

Avatar
6
2
2
6
Relevance

n8n 1.0 - Workflow automation for technical people

24 Jul 2023 Open Source No-Code Developer Tools

n8n is a source-available workflow automation tool designed for technical users. Our low-code platform offers a seamless blend of code and an intuitive interface, serving as the perfect bridge between engineers and other people at your organization.

N8n's 1.0 release is being met with overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating the team on the launch and comeback. Many highlight n8n's sleek design, improved UX, and new features. Users praise its flexibility, intuitive interface, and competitive pricing compared to alternatives like Zapier and Make.com. N8n is considered essential for automation, streamlining workflows, and bridging communication gaps, making it valuable for both technical and non-technical teams. Several users express excitement for personal and professional use.

Users criticize the product's automation capabilities, stating that the paths in Zapier are tedious, and Make's approach is perceived as rigid. This suggests dissatisfaction with the product's flexibility and ease of use in workflow automation.

Avatar
939
76
27.6%
2.6%
76
939
27.6%
2.6%
Relevance

Agentflow – Run Complex LLM Workflows from Simple JSON

08 Aug 2023 Artificial Intelligence No-Code

So, it feels like this should exist. But I couldn't find it. So I tried to build it.Agentflow lets you run complex LLM workflows from a simple JSON file. This can be as little as a list of tasks. Tasks can include variables, so you can reuse workflows for different outputs by providing different variable values. They can also include custom functions, so you can go beyond text generation to do anything you want to write a function for.Someone might say: "Why not just use ChatGPT?" Among other reasons, I'd say that you can't template a workflow with ChatGPT, trigger it with different variable values, easily add in custom functions, or force the use of custom functions for steps in the workflow.Someone might also say: "Then why not use Auto-GPT or BabyAGI?" Among other reasons, I'd say you can't if you want consistency because these tools operate autonomously, creating and executing their own tasks. Agentflow, on the other and, lets you define a step-by-step workflow to give you more control.I'd like to do more with this, including adding more custom functions, and more examples, and more ways to trigger workflows (such as in response to events). But first, I want to make sure I'm not wasting my time! For starters, if something like this already exists, please tell me.

Users suggest collaborations with Magic Loop and API discussion, and recommend using cached AI results for consistency. There's interest in workflow automation tools like api2ai and FlowFlow.AI, as well as open-source alternatives to Step Functions. The tool receives praise for its functionality, with requests for workflow configuration details, examples, and comparisons to LangChain. Curiosity about function calls and image generation is noted. Users express interest in trying the tool, and there are inquiries about support for local LLMs and potential use of LocalAI or FastChat for OpenAI API emulation. The need for a standard LLM API and appreciation for lightweight alternatives to LangChain are also mentioned.

Users criticized the product for lacking AI for user input, requiring Python, needing more examples and a LangChain comparison, unclear statements about 'no code with LangChain', no support for local LLMs, uncertainty about function calling support, lack of a standard for LLM APIs, and the JSON basis being moot without a provided library.

Avatar
51
13
15.4%
13
51
15.4%
Relevance

Workflow automation and collaborative document editing tools

13 Feb 2024 Productivity

I have been a daily HN reader and would like to use this as a starting point to show SimWorkflow so that the HN community can get to know SimWorkflow.This project has been the love child of myself for the past year or so.A bit of background: Previously, I worked as a consultant specializing in designing, implementing, and maintaining Business Process Management and Content Management Solutions. I was surprised at the effort required to implement such solutions; specifically, the time it took, the number of people involved, and the amount of custom code. I thought: What if we could make this easier and make it work with HTTP APIs? So SimWorkflow was eventually born from it.Please feel free to ask any questions. Your feedback is extremely valued, so please let me know what you think!To get started, a new SimWorkflow account comes with an Issue Management solution.Thanks, Tai

Comment is dead.

Avatar
6
1
1
6
Relevance

My affordable solution to costly workflow automation: Embed Workflow

20 May 2023 SaaS Productivity

working on custom workflow software for almost a decade. I built a lean solution with no fluff - and it is free.I am looking for feedback. Anything helps!

Users appreciate the UI and workflow automation but suggest improvements like custom automations, clearer homepage, and better mobile demos. Data privacy concerns lead to a preference for self-deployment. Pricing feedback varies, with some finding it steep and suggesting a subscription model. Minor UI issues like button spacing and capitalization were noted. Open-sourcing the product is recommended to increase usage. Adding 'Show HN' to the title could help attract more feedback.

Users criticized the product for its backend limitations, lack of custom automations, and preference for self-deployment due to data privacy concerns. The product's purpose was found to be unclear, with a poor mobile demo experience and an unclear homepage that lacks workflow demonstrations. It was noted that the product is not listed on Show HN. The pricing was considered high, especially for sites with high churn rates. Users expressed a preference for open-source alternatives for extensive use. The product presentation was perceived as disingenuous, and a minor critique was made regarding the capitalization of 'Slack'.

Avatar
81
11
-18.2%
-27.3%
11
81
9.1%
Relevance

Jotform Workflows - Build Powerful Automations

22 Oct 2024 Productivity Tech Task Management

Work smarter with adaptable workflows that automate complex processes. This free, no-code tool lets you create custom flows that seamlessly trigger the next steps in your process. Automate tasks, streamline approvals, collect payments, and more.

Users express overwhelmingly positive feedback for Jotform's Product Hunt launch. They highlight its power and effectiveness as a solution. Many view Jotform as a game-changer, specifically in the areas of forms, automation, and tables.

Avatar
71
3
3
71
Top