Should I Build It Should I Build It
06 May 2025
Personal Finance Fintech Money

Pennywise, an app that helps you plan and manage your expenses ...

...focusing on saving even pennies and create /link to recurring deposits to save money

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Pennywise, an app focused on meticulous expense tracking and savings automation through recurring deposits, enters a competitive market saturated with similar solutions. With 23 similar products already identified, the landscape is crowded, suggesting a high barrier to entry and the potential for user fatigue. Engagement, as measured by the average number of comments on similar product launches, is low. This indicates that while many apps exist, few are generating significant buzz or sustained user interest. The 'Swamp' category designation suggests that unless Pennywise offers a fundamentally different value proposition, it may struggle to gain traction and differentiate itself from the existing mediocre solutions.

Recommendations

  1. Before diving into development, conduct thorough market research to understand why existing expense tracking and savings apps haven't fully captured users' hearts. What are the common pain points? Where are the gaps in functionality or user experience? This research should inform a unique value proposition for Pennywise.
  2. Instead of targeting everyone, identify a specific niche audience with unmet needs in expense tracking and savings. This could be students, freelancers, or families with specific financial goals. Tailoring Pennywise to a specific demographic will make marketing more effective and allow for more focused feature development. From the similar products, users appreciated shared budget features, so maybe that's something to focus on.
  3. Consider offering Pennywise as a tool for existing financial service providers (banks, credit unions, financial advisors). White-labeling your technology or integrating with their platforms could provide a quicker route to market and leverage their established user bases. Look at the discussion summaries, users have a desire to integrate with existing financial institutions, so think through how you can partner with them.
  4. Explore adjacent problems related to personal finance that might be more compelling or less saturated. Could you focus on debt management, investment planning, or financial education, using expense tracking as a supporting feature rather than the primary focus? One product pivoted to focusing on the AI aspect of it, which could be interesting.
  5. Carefully evaluate the level of automation Pennywise offers. The similar product 'Expense Now' faced criticism regarding the amount of manual input required. Aim to minimize manual data entry through smart integrations and automated categorization to enhance user convenience.
  6. Since users seem to be excited about AI integrations, consider leveraging AI to provide personalized saving advice. The similar product Timmy, uses AI to help better manage personal finances, and that seems to be a key selling point. Research what similar AI tools they have and how you can differentiate.
  7. Don't rely on Pennywise's features alone to stand out. Think about the name! 'FML' was criticized for having a negative connotation, so invest in a name, logo, and brand that resonates with a positive outlook on saving money.

Questions

  1. What specific, unique features will Pennywise offer that truly differentiate it from the dozens of other expense tracking apps already available, and how will you validate that these features resonate with your target audience?
  2. Given the low engagement observed in similar products, what innovative marketing and user acquisition strategies will you employ to generate initial traction and sustain long-term user interest in Pennywise?
  3. How will Pennywise ensure user data privacy and security, and what steps will you take to build trust and transparency with users in an environment where financial data breaches are a growing concern?

Your are here

Pennywise, an app focused on meticulous expense tracking and savings automation through recurring deposits, enters a competitive market saturated with similar solutions. With 23 similar products already identified, the landscape is crowded, suggesting a high barrier to entry and the potential for user fatigue. Engagement, as measured by the average number of comments on similar product launches, is low. This indicates that while many apps exist, few are generating significant buzz or sustained user interest. The 'Swamp' category designation suggests that unless Pennywise offers a fundamentally different value proposition, it may struggle to gain traction and differentiate itself from the existing mediocre solutions.

Recommendations

  1. Before diving into development, conduct thorough market research to understand why existing expense tracking and savings apps haven't fully captured users' hearts. What are the common pain points? Where are the gaps in functionality or user experience? This research should inform a unique value proposition for Pennywise.
  2. Instead of targeting everyone, identify a specific niche audience with unmet needs in expense tracking and savings. This could be students, freelancers, or families with specific financial goals. Tailoring Pennywise to a specific demographic will make marketing more effective and allow for more focused feature development. From the similar products, users appreciated shared budget features, so maybe that's something to focus on.
  3. Consider offering Pennywise as a tool for existing financial service providers (banks, credit unions, financial advisors). White-labeling your technology or integrating with their platforms could provide a quicker route to market and leverage their established user bases. Look at the discussion summaries, users have a desire to integrate with existing financial institutions, so think through how you can partner with them.
  4. Explore adjacent problems related to personal finance that might be more compelling or less saturated. Could you focus on debt management, investment planning, or financial education, using expense tracking as a supporting feature rather than the primary focus? One product pivoted to focusing on the AI aspect of it, which could be interesting.
  5. Carefully evaluate the level of automation Pennywise offers. The similar product 'Expense Now' faced criticism regarding the amount of manual input required. Aim to minimize manual data entry through smart integrations and automated categorization to enhance user convenience.
  6. Since users seem to be excited about AI integrations, consider leveraging AI to provide personalized saving advice. The similar product Timmy, uses AI to help better manage personal finances, and that seems to be a key selling point. Research what similar AI tools they have and how you can differentiate.
  7. Don't rely on Pennywise's features alone to stand out. Think about the name! 'FML' was criticized for having a negative connotation, so invest in a name, logo, and brand that resonates with a positive outlook on saving money.

Questions

  1. What specific, unique features will Pennywise offer that truly differentiate it from the dozens of other expense tracking apps already available, and how will you validate that these features resonate with your target audience?
  2. Given the low engagement observed in similar products, what innovative marketing and user acquisition strategies will you employ to generate initial traction and sustain long-term user interest in Pennywise?
  3. How will Pennywise ensure user data privacy and security, and what steps will you take to build trust and transparency with users in an environment where financial data breaches are a growing concern?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 23
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 1
  • Net use signal: 32.8%
    • Positive use signal: 32.8%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Timmy - Save money faster with Timmy

05 Sep 2024 iOS Artificial Intelligence Finance

Timmy is an AI spending buddy, designed to help you save money. Download the app, link your bank, choose a savings goal, and watch as Timmy helps you reach it. He generates tailored suggestions, spending activity alerts, monthly budget alerts, and more!

Users are excited about Timmy's launch, highlighting its innovative AI-driven approach to financial management. A key feature mentioned is the subscription tracking capability, which is seen as useful for better managing personal finances.

Avatar
5
2
100.0%
2
5
100.0%
Relevance

Built an AI Money Tracker as Soloprenuer

13 Sep 2024 Personal Finance Artificial Intelligence Money

Hello everyone, I was always thinking about how I can increase my finances to get out of the rat race. Apart from increasing my income, the other approach I did is to reduce my expenses and hence I started my journey on expense tracking.I have tried a few apps and most of the time these apps are too complicated and I didn't manage to consistently key in my expense. Though there are some apps that provide link to bank account spending but I think that defeats the purpose of expense tracker since I believe only by manually input your spending in, only you'll be aware of your spending.This drives me to have a thought about how can I improve this and I decided to create my own app to make this work. I created Rolly: AI Money Tracker - a new AI expense tracker where you can easily record your transactions just by chatting with our bot Rolly and it will automatically record and categorise the transaction into the most suitable category (you can also create any of your own category and it will also take care of it in consideration). Demo video here. More features like budgeting are on the way, stay tuned!App Store: https://apps.apple.com/au/app/rolly-ai-money-tracker/id66365...Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jc.rollymo...Anyone that have any feedback or needs for any new feature, do feel free to let me know and I'm happy to discuss and incorporate it. Thanks.

Cool app, AI seems angry, needs currency conversion.

AI seems angry, needs currency conversion.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Tripot - Track, budget, and save—all in one app.

01 Oct 2024 Budgeting Personal Finance Money

Efficiently manage your personal finances with our intuitive app. Track daily expenses, categorize spending, and set realistic budgets to achieve your financial goals. Stay on top of your financial health and make smarter decisions with ease.

Tripot simplifies expense splitting and budgeting, reducing financial stress.

Avatar
14
1
100.0%
1
14
100.0%
Relevance

Rocky App - Budget & expense tracker

21 Feb 2023 Productivity Tech

Rocky App – income & expense tracker app is the perfect tool to help you manage your finances and stay on top of your expenses. Manage daily expenses, plan a personal budget, create categories & groups, and spend wisely.

Avatar
70
70
Relevance

FinWise – The modern way to manage your personal finances

30 Oct 2023 Fintech Personal Finance

Hi everyone, I'd like to share FinWise (https://finwiseapp.io) with you, which my wife and I have been building over the last few months.FinWise is an all-in-one personal finance management tool, including budgeting, net-worth tracking, financial planning & forecasting and a couple of other things which we're still busy working on like couples/family budgeting and being able to set and track goals.It's designed to make managing all your personal finances as simple, easy and painless as possible, and we've put a lot of effort into making the website as simple and intuitive, whilst still being powerful and offering a comprehensive set of personal finance tools.A non-exhaustive list of things you can do with FinWise:- Connect your bank & investments accounts with Plaid & Yodlee (Or manual imports). - Currently US, CA and ZA. EU, NZ, AU and others coming soon!- Track and visualize your net-worth.- Budget and save money.- AI transaction categorization (You almost never have to manually categorize your transactions).- Transaction splitting, tags, notes and attachments.- Import transactions with CSV files from Mint/Empower etc.- Export account, transaction and insights data to CSV.- Plan, project and forecast your future finances (In beta).- Spending, saving and net-worth insights and analytics.- Multi-currency support.- Goals and goal-tracking (Coming soon).- Developer API access (Coming soon).- iOS/Android app (Coming soon).- Privacy-focused. No ads, selling data or anything like that.- Just about SOC2 and ISO compliant (No certificates yet, but I've done a few SOC2 certifications in the past.)We made FinWise because we were not able to find a personal finance tool out there which offered all the features we wanted, and which was simple, intuitive and easy to use. There are lots of personal finances apps around, but we felt most were either too basic, over-complicated or too expensive, or limiting in some way.We're now on a mission to build the best personal finance app out there, and to help as many people as possible to better save, grow and manage their money.If you'd like to learn more and try it out, head over to our website: https://finwiseapp.ioIf you have any feedback or questions, please let me know :)Find us on X/Twitter: Me: https://twitter.com/jasrusable Nicol: https://twitter.com/NicolNvojacek FinWise: https://twitter.com/FinwiseappPS: There are some interesting technical aspects of the project that we are particularly proud of which I am planning to do more in-depth posts on soon, namely:- How we implemented our AI transaction categorization system.- How we built the entire website to use optimistic loading, so no loading states.- How we kept the codebases extremely simple and intuitive, allowing us to move quickly.- Going open source once we hit critical mass.

Avatar
9
9
Relevance

My side project is helping me manage my finances

27 Dec 2023 Fintech Personal Finance Artificial Intelligence

For years, I have struggled to understand my cash flow and save for the future. In addition to that, my wife has many credit cards and accounts that complicate matters. I am building a tool that connects all our accounts, helps us create a budget, and tracks and adjusts expenses on the fly. I am also sprinkling some AI magic on it for financial suggestions. I am looking for feedback on the implementation. More importantly, I am looking for more beta testers to improve the product.

The Show HN product, FML, is recognized for simplifying financial planning and review. Users have concerns about the association with a well-known initialism potentially being detrimental. There is curiosity about the AI's functionality and questions regarding integration with financial institutions. The product has received positive remarks on its appearance. Some comments are no longer active.

Users suggest rethinking the use of the initialism 'FML' due to its commonly known negative connotation, which contrasts with the intended message.

Avatar
9
7
7
9
Relevance

Budgety - Budgeting, expense tracking, money manager

09 Jul 2024 Android Personal Finance Money

Budgety is a budgeting, expense tracking and money management app. Track your income, expenses, savings and progress towards your financial goals. Analyze your spending patterns, goals, identify areas for improvement and make informed decisions

Users appreciate the shared budget feature for financial tracking and the fast onboarding process. The personalized transaction notes are useful for expense tracking, and the app provides valuable spending insights to identify potential areas for cutbacks.

Avatar
7
4
75.0%
4
7
75.0%
Relevance

Expense Now – Money Organizer - Track, Budget, Save and Take Control of Your Finances

30 Aug 2024 Android Personal Finance Money

Expense Now is a user-friendly budgeting app that helps you track your income and expenses effortlessly. With its intuitive interface and powerful features, Expense Now empowers you to take control of your finances and make informed financial decisions.

Expense Now app is being lauded for simplifying expense tracking and budgeting. Users appreciate features like receipt photo uploads and expense categorization. Several users inquired about the app's differentiation, user experience (UX), and the availability of a freemium model. There's also interest in manual expense input. Overall, the app is considered handy and helpful, showing promise after its launch.

The primary criticism raised is the extent of manual input required to effectively use the product. Users are questioning the level of automation and the amount of hands-on effort needed, implying a potential concern about the product's efficiency or ease of use.

Avatar
7
7
42.9%
7
7
42.9%
Relevance

Plootus - Your financial & retirement planning companion

05 Nov 2024 Fintech Personal Finance Money

Plootus is a revolutionary personal finance app designed to help users take control of their financial future. It offers features like budgeting, expense tracking, investment insights & personalized financial advice, with a focus on 401k retirement planning.

Easy, user-friendly financial planning app with actionable 401k management advice.

Avatar
3
1
100.0%
1
3
100.0%
Top