Should I Build It Should I Build It
19 Apr 2025
Advertising Marketing

advertisement platform that lets advertisements be presented on ...

...websites for the niche market for the product

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

You're entering a market with a moderate level of competition: we've identified 18 similar advertisement platforms, suggesting that the concept of niche ad platforms is validated but not without competition. These platforms often focus on connecting advertisers with specific audiences. Engagement is medium, suggesting there's conversation around these platforms, but not overwhelming buzz. The idea category 'Freemium' suggests users like the idea of these platforms, but are hesitant to pay, so you'll need to focus on differentiation and monetization. Given the competitive landscape, it's important to consider how your platform will stand out and how you will convince users to pay for premium features, or how to monetize through a B2B strategy. It looks like there are opportunities, as the comments on similar products suggest people are searching for better ad platforms and streamlined experiences. This is encouraging news, but you should keep your eye on the ball regarding how to sustainably monetize your product, and differentiate yourself from Google Ads, while also making it easier to use than other alternatives.

Recommendations

  1. Given that you're in the 'Freemium' category, begin by identifying which users derive the most value from the free version of your advertisement platform. Understanding their needs and pain points will inform the development of premium features that cater specifically to them.
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the experience for high-value users. These could include advanced analytics, enhanced targeting options, priority support, or integrations with other key marketing tools. Focus on features that solve real problems and justify a premium price.
  3. Explore the possibility of charging teams or agencies rather than individual users. This can provide a more sustainable revenue stream, as teams are more likely to have dedicated budgets for advertising tools. Consider tiered pricing based on team size and usage.
  4. Offer personalized help, onboarding or consulting services to premium users. This can increase the perceived value of your platform and provide an additional revenue stream. Consider offering workshops, one-on-one training, or custom strategy sessions.
  5. Implement A/B testing on different pricing approaches with small groups of users. This will help you identify the optimal price point and packaging for your premium features. Pay close attention to conversion rates and customer feedback.
  6. Based on feedback from similar products, focus on making your platform incredibly easy to integrate and use. Many users seek simple, streamlined solutions. Prioritize a user-friendly interface and intuitive workflows.
  7. Address the need for robust analytics. Users want transparency and control over their ad campaigns. Provide detailed reporting and analytics dashboards that allow advertisers to track their performance and optimize their strategies effectively. It may be worth building your own platform for this, instead of relying on Google Analytics or similar solutions.
  8. Offer stronger customer support, particularly for less tech-savvy users. Consider creating detailed tutorials, FAQs, and video guides to help users get the most out of your platform. Make it easy for users to contact your support team and get quick, helpful responses.
  9. Consider innovative ad formats. Newsletter advertising, audio ads (podcasts) and video ads seem to resonate with users looking for new ways to reach niche markets.
  10. Given concerns about selling out, prioritize user data protection and avoid intrusive ad practices. Be transparent about how you collect and use data, and give users control over their privacy settings. Consider privacy-focused features that resonate with users seeking to maintain the integrity and authenticity of their content.

Questions

  1. What specific niche market are you targeting, and how will your platform provide unique value compared to existing solutions like Google Ads or niche ad networks?
  2. How will you balance offering a free version of your platform with incentivizing users to upgrade to premium features, and what metrics will you use to track the success of your monetization strategy?
  3. Given user concerns about transparency and control, how will you ensure that your platform provides advertisers with detailed analytics and reporting while also protecting user privacy and data?

Your are here

You're entering a market with a moderate level of competition: we've identified 18 similar advertisement platforms, suggesting that the concept of niche ad platforms is validated but not without competition. These platforms often focus on connecting advertisers with specific audiences. Engagement is medium, suggesting there's conversation around these platforms, but not overwhelming buzz. The idea category 'Freemium' suggests users like the idea of these platforms, but are hesitant to pay, so you'll need to focus on differentiation and monetization. Given the competitive landscape, it's important to consider how your platform will stand out and how you will convince users to pay for premium features, or how to monetize through a B2B strategy. It looks like there are opportunities, as the comments on similar products suggest people are searching for better ad platforms and streamlined experiences. This is encouraging news, but you should keep your eye on the ball regarding how to sustainably monetize your product, and differentiate yourself from Google Ads, while also making it easier to use than other alternatives.

Recommendations

  1. Given that you're in the 'Freemium' category, begin by identifying which users derive the most value from the free version of your advertisement platform. Understanding their needs and pain points will inform the development of premium features that cater specifically to them.
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the experience for high-value users. These could include advanced analytics, enhanced targeting options, priority support, or integrations with other key marketing tools. Focus on features that solve real problems and justify a premium price.
  3. Explore the possibility of charging teams or agencies rather than individual users. This can provide a more sustainable revenue stream, as teams are more likely to have dedicated budgets for advertising tools. Consider tiered pricing based on team size and usage.
  4. Offer personalized help, onboarding or consulting services to premium users. This can increase the perceived value of your platform and provide an additional revenue stream. Consider offering workshops, one-on-one training, or custom strategy sessions.
  5. Implement A/B testing on different pricing approaches with small groups of users. This will help you identify the optimal price point and packaging for your premium features. Pay close attention to conversion rates and customer feedback.
  6. Based on feedback from similar products, focus on making your platform incredibly easy to integrate and use. Many users seek simple, streamlined solutions. Prioritize a user-friendly interface and intuitive workflows.
  7. Address the need for robust analytics. Users want transparency and control over their ad campaigns. Provide detailed reporting and analytics dashboards that allow advertisers to track their performance and optimize their strategies effectively. It may be worth building your own platform for this, instead of relying on Google Analytics or similar solutions.
  8. Offer stronger customer support, particularly for less tech-savvy users. Consider creating detailed tutorials, FAQs, and video guides to help users get the most out of your platform. Make it easy for users to contact your support team and get quick, helpful responses.
  9. Consider innovative ad formats. Newsletter advertising, audio ads (podcasts) and video ads seem to resonate with users looking for new ways to reach niche markets.
  10. Given concerns about selling out, prioritize user data protection and avoid intrusive ad practices. Be transparent about how you collect and use data, and give users control over their privacy settings. Consider privacy-focused features that resonate with users seeking to maintain the integrity and authenticity of their content.

Questions

  1. What specific niche market are you targeting, and how will your platform provide unique value compared to existing solutions like Google Ads or niche ad networks?
  2. How will you balance offering a free version of your platform with incentivizing users to upgrade to premium features, and what metrics will you use to track the success of your monetization strategy?
  3. Given user concerns about transparency and control, how will you ensure that your platform provides advertisers with detailed analytics and reporting while also protecting user privacy and data?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 18
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 10
  • Net use signal: 16.2%
    • Positive use signal: 16.2%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Open For Ads - A free platform to connect independent medias & advertisers

19 Feb 2023 Advertising Social Media Marketing

Open For Ads is a platform to connect independent media and advertisers. Simple, Free and without commissions.

Nico's Product Hunt launch of "Open For Ads" received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating Nico and praising the product's usefulness for independent media owners seeking sponsorships and monetization. Users appreciate the platform's streamlined design, ease of use, and features like transparent ad tracking and advertiser search. Open For Ads is seen as a win-win solution, prioritizing user data protection, and is commended for being free and commission-free. Many express excitement to try the platform and believe it addresses a significant need for creators, bloggers, and newsletter publishers.

Users inquired about the pricing model, specifically if the platform takes a cut of the budget or uses a subscription model. There was a comparison to other ad platforms that deduct a percentage from earnings, suggesting a concern about potential costs.

ericlamideas

love it Nico. big fan. Excited to try this out!

guru_patel1

Open For Ads is a great platform for independent media owners to monetize their content. I've already connected with several advertisers through the platform!

nithin_jawahar

We're looking to monetize our newsletter shortly through sponsors and I think open for ads is a great place to start. Thanks for making this @nicolas_jeanne 🤗

mehulsharmamat

Fascinating idea, will try it for my next product! Good luck nico! :D

karthik_tatikonda

Congratulations on the launch 🎉🎉 This is really helpful for makers who are building resource sites like me. Thanks for building this Nico!!

richard_gao2

Congrats on the launch! This is going to be very useful with all the AI newsletters coming out haha

verasun

Interesting product and congrats on your launch! Love that it came with a ad profit calculating tool. I used to run a news site and I had to cold-email sponsors one by one. Think Open For Ads would have been a wonderful way to shortcut the process if it has a good amount of willing sponsors!

inder_chahal

I love that Open For Ads is free to use and doesn't take any commissions. It's a refreshing change from other ad platforms that take a cut of your earnings.

pratibha_aggarwa

As an independent media owner, it's been really hard to find good advertising partners. Open For Ads has been a lifesaver - I've already connected with several advertisers that are a great fit for my audience.

sourav_verma1

I've already earned more money from Open For Ads than I have from other ad platforms. I think the fact that it's designed specifically for independent media owners makes a huge difference.

ilya_golovin1

This is exaclty what I was looking for! Let try it out :)

dmytro_krasun

Congratulations on the launch, Nico! It is a good niche that will always stay relevant. I will consider adding my media platforms to it 👌

dagorenouf

This will come in handy. thanks for building this

johannesplayground

Nice work Nico! I hope it’ll work out and I’ll be able to use it, both as a creator and an advertiser.

thomas_sanlis1

A fantastic idea that will probably be very helpful to me, thank you Nico 🙏

arnab_ghosh

Congrats @nicolas_jeanne on the launch! After my project gets some good numbers, openforads will be a great resource to start with ads!

mischamillion

Congrats on the Launch @nicolas_jeanne 🥳🎉 Hahah what a story (hope you're better now) It's an amazing idea I was looking for a tool like that the other day 🙏 So thanks, I'll now check it out in full details. Best success

Avatar
321
78
21.8%
78
321
21.8%
Relevance

Stuff to Sponsor | Boostrapped Product - Discover Top Sites to Buy Ad Spots

13 Oct 2024 Advertising Tech Marketing

Discover top sites to buy ad spots. Explore niche-specific platforms and secure prime advertising spots for your brand.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users finding the directory useful for publishers seeking advertising program exposure. Users bookmarked the project for future use and praised its potential, with one user drawing a comparison to Mediavine for indie makers. There is a desire for more options within the directory.

The main criticism is the desire for more options within the directory. Users are looking for a more comprehensive selection to enhance their experience.

Avatar
21
5
40.0%
5
21
40.0%
Relevance

Fucimo – Simplifying Ad Buying for Everyone

24 Nov 2023 Advertising Marketing

Hello HN. We're Ezgi and Yunus. We built Fucimo: https://fucimo.com. a marketplace designed to make ad buying and selling as frictionless as possible. Our goal was to create a solution that works efficiently across different media channels, providing both ad buyers and sellers with a platform that's easy to navigate. We believe in making the complex simple. Looking forward to your insights and feedback!In today's fragmented media environment, advertisers and publishers face significant challenges. The process of buying and selling ads across various channels – from digital to print, and outdoor to broadcast – is fraught with inefficiencies. Each channel operates in its silo, often with differing standards and processes, making it difficult for ad buyers to execute a cohesive, cross-channel strategy. This fragmentation not only hampers the effectiveness of advertising campaigns but also leads to wasted resources and time. Fucimo is designed to bridge these gaps, offering a unified platform that brings coherence to multi-channel ad transactions.We know we don't have all the answers, and that's why your thoughts are so valuable to us. By listening to what you have to say, we can see things from different points of view and find new ways to improve. Your feedback is a big part of this journey, helping us to learn, adapt, and become better at what we do. Again, looking forward to your insights and feedback!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

VantagoAds - You own your ads platform

25 Nov 2023 Advertising SaaS Marketing

VantagoAds: Revolutionize your ad strategy with our custom ad server. Monetize websites & apps fast. Easy integration, fast connections, & secure SSL included.

VantagoAds' Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and praising the platform's ease of integration and security. The revolutionary approach to ad strategy was noted, along with its decentralized ownership, pricing, advertising, analytics, and potential ROI. A question was raised about VantagoAds' differentiation from Google Ads, and a feature request for audio ads was made. Strong customer support was emphasized as crucial. Users also expressed interest in the platform's secure connections.

Users suggest adding robust analytics for better strategy. Stronger customer support is needed, particularly for less tech-savvy individuals. There's a missed opportunity in audio ads, specifically in podcast advertising. As a new platform with a decentralized model, onboarding is essential due to its limited reach.

Avatar
43
12
12
43
Relevance

Newsletter Ad Network by beehiiv - Make a Fortune 500 brand your next newsletter sponsor

09 Aug 2024 Advertising SaaS Newsletters

The beehiiv Ad Network is like having a full ad sales team on call. With one click, you can place native ads (from brands like Netflix and Hubspot) in your newsletter. We handle all the tracking, reporting, and invoicing—so you can sit back and earn.

Beehiiv's Newsletter Ad Network launch is generating excitement, particularly for its creative control, placement flexibility, and potential for increased ROI for newsletter creators. Users appreciate the platform's ability to simplify newsletter management with its no-code approach and powerful editing tools. The ad sales team and enhanced monetization are also viewed positively. Some express concerns about ad relevance, potential brand dominance, and the feeling of 'selling out' with more ads, but remain open-minded. Overall, feedback is highly positive, praising Beehiiv as a game-changer and a tool that users stick with once they start using it.

Users expressed concerns about the balance between creative control and user experience/feedback. There's anxiety that larger brands might overshadow independent newsletters on the platform. The potential for increased advertising within newsletters is seen negatively, with some users feeling it compromises the integrity and authenticity of the content.

Avatar
208
25
28.0%
25
208
28.0%
Top